Don Hosek - Democratic Primary 2004 Death Pool (how wrong can I get?)
Commentary

27 Feb 2004: Student teaching is killing me. I've had two drop-outs since the last update, and enough time is past that I'm not even going to put dates or links on those. This is becoming an exercise in how wrong I can be in my predictions. This is almost as bad as that article a friend wrote predicting that the Berlin Wall wouldn't come tumbling down anytime soon, which appeared in print, the day after the Berlin Wall was, in fact, torn down.

Incidentally, with Howard Dean's drop-out, I've officially crossed the line into statistical insignificance.

5 Feb 2004: I've been a bit busy this week, so I didn't get to update this page with the Lieberman drop-out. Things are still looking bad for Dean and all signs are that if Wisconsin doesn't go for Dean, then Dean will pack it in. Dean managed to put together a devoted base, but never really expanded his following beyond his base. It's a pity because he demonstrated that he would have been a good leader for the democratic party, with some of the ways that he motivated his supporters to back some candidates further down the ticket. I hope that he does pack the eventual nominee.

27 Jan 2004: It's starting to look my predictions might be as wrong as can be. Lieberman is likely to be next to drop, and I'd expect to see Clark not too far behind him. At this point, my prognostication (not that they've been any good thusfar) will have Kerry, Edwards and Dean taking it all the way. Dean's second place finish in NH is not a good sign for him, but we'll see what happens with his greater financial backing as the primary expands in the larger arena. Kucinich and Sharpton are more likely to stay in because they're more vanity candidates anyway and they have no reason to drop out as long as they keep getting invitations to the debates.

19 Jan 2004: Wow, Iowa has shown that the conventional wisdom can be way off. Everyone had expected this to be a race between Dean and Gephardt. Instead they came in 3rd and 4th! My expectation is that this won't dramatically impact Dean, but Gephardt, who I had effectively picked as a second place finish after Dean is probably out.

14 Jan 2004: Well my hopes of a perfect score have been dashed with Carol Moseley-Braun dropping out sooner than expected.

16 Nov 2003: Who's laughing now? When I first posted this, there was a great deal of scorn on my picking Kerry as second to drop out of the race, but as the news has developed with Kerry's campaign beginning to appear desparate and in disarray, my prediction looks quite good indeed.

My predictions for the order in which candidates will drop out of the democratic primary (my list was created in September, just before Clark got in the race). Success rates are given using Spearman Rank-Order Correlation Coefficients, assuming that all future dropouts follow the expected result. A value of 1.0 for rs indicates a perfect prediction, 0.0 indicates completely inaccurate correlation. p indicates the chances that I got these results by luck alone. Smaller is better.

For the numbers that do matter, CNN has a handy Delegate scorecard.

Predicted order Actual order
(drop-out date)
Probability score
Bob Graham Graham (10/6) rs=1.0, p<.001
John Kerry Moseley-Braun (1/15) rs=0.99, p<.001
Carol Moseley-Braun Gephardt (1/20) rs=0.86, p<.002
Joseph Lieberman Lieberman (2/3) rs=0.83, p<.002
Dennis Kucinich Wesley Clark rs=0.70, p<.026
John Edwards1 Howard Dean rs=0.53, p<.117
Dick Gephardt --
Wesley Clark --
Howard Dean --
Al Sharpton2 --

1. Edwards will bawl like Daryl Issa at the press conference when he announces his withdrawal from the race.

2. Sharpton will never officially withdraw from the race, even after all of his staff have quit.

It occurs to me that I may as well go on record with the revelation that I have never voted for the winning candidate in a presidential election (primary or general) in my life. My history (all candidates are democrats unless otherwise indicated):

Year Election My candidate
1988 Primary Jesse Jackson
General Michael Dukakis
1992 Primary Bob Kerry
General Ron Daniels (Peace & Freedom)
1996 Primary Jerry Brown
General Marsha Feinland (Peace & Freedom)1
2000 Primary Bill Bradley
General Ralph Nader (Green)2

1. I think. I might have voted Nader that year.

2. It's not my fault Gore lost. Gore won my state in 2000 by a healthy margin. Had the polling indicated a close election, I probably would have voted for Gore. I'm a flaming liberal, but I'm not an idiot. Gore lost because he and Lieberman ran a lousy campaign.